“She saved the world.
A lot.”
Now it's our turn to save her.
What Just Happened
February 2025: Hulu greenlit a pilot for a Buffy the Vampire Slayer reboot — Buffy: New Sunnydale. Oscar-winner Chloé Zhao signed on to direct. Ryan Kiera Armstrong was cast as the new Slayer. And then — the moment fans had waited two decades for — Sarah Michelle Gellar herself returned as Buffy Summers, executive producer and star. Even Dolly Parton was on board as an executive producer.
The pilot was written by the team behind Poker Face. The cast was assembled. The cameras rolled. The pilot was shot.
“It is with a heavy heart that I share that Hulu has decided not to move forward with Buffy: New Sunnydale... I want to thank the incredible team who worked so hard to bring this project to life. And to the fans — you have never stopped fighting for Buffy. Please don't stop now.”
— Sarah Michelle Gellar, Instagram · March 14, 2026 ↗And today, March 14, 2026, Hulu pulled the plug.
But here's what Hulu also said: “The door is still open.”
We need to walk through it.
Why Buffy Matters
The Original
1997–2003
7 seasons. 144 episodes. First on The WB, then UPN. Buffy Summers wasn't just a vampire slayer — she was a feminist icon, a metaphor for the horrors of adolescence, a girl who died twice and kept fighting. Creator Joss Whedon built a universe where the monsters were always real, and the stakes were always personal.
The Legacy
Still Slaying
Spawned the spinoff Angel (5 seasons, 110 episodes). Influenced virtually every YA fantasy that followed — from Charmed to Supernatural to The Vampire Diaries. Academic courses taught it. Books were written about it. It's still in active syndication and streaming globally, still finding new fans 25+ years later.
The Reboot Vision
New Sunnydale
Ryan Kiera Armstrong as a new Slayer. Sarah Michelle Gellar back as Buffy. Directed by Chloé Zhao (Nomadland, Eternals). Written by the Poker Face team. Executive produced by SMG — and Dolly Parton. This wasn't a cash-grab. This was a love letter, from people who understood exactly what Buffy means.
Cultural Footprint
“Buffy is to TV what Ulysses is to the novel — a complete reinvention of what the form can do.”— Entertainment Weekly
Before & After Buffy
Before Buffy
Female leads in genre TV were rare. The "chosen one" was almost always male. Horror was a man's world.
Buffy Premieres
A teenage girl defeats a master vampire, saves the world, and dies — before coming back for six more seasons.
Hush (S4)
Near-silent episode earns an Emmy nomination. TV realizes silence can be cinema.
Once More With Feeling (S6)
The musical episode rewrites what a TV show can attempt. Becomes a cultural template.
The Legacy Begins
Angel, Firefly, and a wave of creator-driven genre TV follow in Buffy's wake.
The Descendants
Supernatural. TVD. Arrow. Teen Wolf. Grimm. Every show with a "chosen one" protagonist owes a debt.
Now
The pilot exists. The cast is assembled. The world is still ready.
Sign the Petition
The Petition Letter
To: Dana Walden (Chairman, Disney Entertainment), Joe Earley (President, Hulu), and the Executive Leadership of The Walt Disney Company and Hulu,
We the undersigned call on Hulu and Disney to reconsider the cancellation of Buffy: New Sunnydale.
The pilot exists. The cast is assembled. Sarah Michelle Gellar has returned. Ryan Kiera Armstrong is ready to take the mantle. Chloé Zhao has delivered a vision. The world is ready.
Buffy the Vampire Slayer is not just a franchise — it is a cultural institution. Its story deserves to continue. Its new chapter deserves to be seen. You have already made the investment. The only thing left is to give the world the show it has earned.
Give us the Slayer.
Spread the Word
Every Slayer needs her Scoobies. Share the petition, tag Hulu, make some noise. The internet saved shows before — and it can do it again.
Copy & Paste
“Hulu pulled the plug on Buffy: New Sunnydale with the pilot already shot. SMG was back. The door is still open. Sign the petition: savebuffy.com #SaveBuffy”